Turn a community disagreement into a testable question

Given [POSITION A], [POSITION B], and [SHARED DECISION], write a neutral brief stating each concern in its strongest fair form. Separate factual disputes from value differences, list evidence that could resolve each factual issue, and propose one reversible pilot with a stop rule. Do not invent consensus or use loaded labels. Check that both sides can recognise their position and that the pilot does not override safety or rights constraints.